Match Your MedicareA non-government entity powered bycareCycle

I kept hearing from people after they enrolled. So we built what they needed before.

I’m Alex Doonanco, co-founder of careCycle. Match Your Medicare is a free, independent way to compare Medicare plans by what you’d actually pay. Here’s why we built it.

An older man in glasses sits at a wooden desk, using a laptop that shows the Match Your Medicare homepage and a video guide asking for microphone access.
My grandpa testing out Match Your Medicare for the first time.

The calls that come after

At careCycle, we build customer service tools for Medicare agencies, the companies that help people enroll in plans and support them afterward. Our AI assistants make the calls most agencies never had time for: a welcome call after you enroll, a check-in a few months later to ask whether you’ve seen your doctor and whether your prescriptions cost what you expected, a reminder before a benefit runs out.

Our assistants have spent more than 30,000 hours on the phone with people on Medicare, and we’ve helped agencies support more than a million people after they enrolled. Again and again, I heard the same thing. A few months in, people find out a drug they take isn’t covered, or a visit costs more than they expected. Those questions could have been answered in about ten minutes before they signed up. Almost nobody asks them then.

Six plans in three months

I noticed something else: how often people change plans. Agents can look up a person’s enrollment history, and it isn’t unusual to see someone who has switched plans six times in three months. That isn’t careful shopping. It’s someone being passed from one sales call to the next.

Once you’ve answered a Medicare ad, you keep seeing more of them, even after you’ve enrolled. Each new call can go to a different agent, who earns a new commission on a new plan. That doesn’t help you, and it doesn’t help the insurance companies or the agents trying to do right by their clients either.

Why it keeps happening

  • The ads sell the extras

    Medicare ads are designed to get you to call, and they lead with extras like grocery allowances, over-the-counter cards and money back on your Part B premium. Your call is often sold to whichever agency pays the most. Many people pick a plan for the extras before anyone checks that their doctors and prescriptions are covered.

  • The clock is always running

    Most agents are paid when you sign up, not for how well the plan works for you over time. That makes for rushed conversations, and important details about your health and budget get missed. Insurance companies are starting to push back on this, but it hasn't gone away.

  • No one sees every plan

    Agents can only offer plans from the insurance companies they work with, and many are required to tell you so: “We do not offer every plan available in your area.” Even a great agent can only find you the best plan they're able to sell.

None of this is a knock on agents. It’s how the system is set up, and it’s hard on the best ones too.

Why this year matters

Insurance companies keep pulling plans out of whole counties, and when that happens to your plan, you have to choose a new one.

1 million

people on Medicare will see their plan stop serving their county this year.

Approximate, from recent CMS data

That’s become a yearly disruption. Until 2024, plan exits affected about 1% of Medicare Advantage members a year. In 2026 it was 10%, roughly 2.9 million people.

If your plan is ending, you’ll get a letter. The bigger risk is a plan that stays but quietly changes: the monthly premium looks the same while your copays double, or the most you could pay in a year goes from $2,000 to $4,000. Nobody is required to walk you through that, so it’s worth checking your plan every fall. You can switch during Medicare’s Open Enrollment, October 15 to December 7.

What we built

Match Your Medicare is a free, neutral place to see which plans fit you before you talk to anyone selling one. You enter your ZIP code, then your doctors, prescriptions and any health conditions you’d like to include.

Instead of sorting plans by monthly premium, it estimates what each plan would cost you over a whole year (premium, copays and drug costs together), based on what people with similar health conditions and prescriptions actually spend. It also shows which plans keep your doctors. You can compare up to three side by side, then take what you’ve learned to an advisor, a family member, or Medicare.

If you’d rather talk than type, our video guide can walk you through each step, explain why each question is asked, and fill in the form as you speak. It doesn’t recommend plans, and it won’t pass you to a salesperson.

My first tester

In late September I was at my grandpa’s house helping him set up his printer, and I asked him to try the site. I didn’t explain anything; I just watched. He’s about 80. He typed in his ZIP code and started the video guide on his own, then got stuck at the microphone prompt and the button to join the call. That’s the moment in the photo above.

We took that step out. Now the conversation starts as soon as you allow your microphone. Every person who tries Match Your Medicare shows us something we can make simpler.

Why it’s free

Because it’s an experiment. careCycle earns its money from the software we sell to Medicare agencies, not from this site. Match Your Medicare isn’t paid by insurance companies, takes no commissions, doesn’t sell or share your information, and won’t connect you with an agent.

I want to find out whether people want clear, unbiased answers before they talk to anyone selling a plan. I think that’s better for everyone, including the agencies we work with: people who land in the right plan the first time tend to stay.

Where we’re headed

We imagine a world where choosing a Medicare plan is as easy as picking an ice cream flavor.

Then licensed advisors can spend their time where it matters most: giving their clients quality, holistic support. Match Your Medicare is our first experiment in making that world real.

careCycle co-founders Evan Roubekas and Alex Doonanco standing together in an office hallway.

Who we are

Evan Roubekas and I co-founded careCycle to give Medicare agencies customer service that keeps working after the sale. We’re backed by Y Combinator.

Match Your Medicare grew out of years of that work: thousands of hours with licensed agents, tens of thousands of hours of calls with people on Medicare, and what we learned along the way.

careCycle co-founders Evan Roubekas and Alex Doonanco presenting together at a Y Combinator event.
Evan and me presenting careCycle at Y Combinator.

Thank you for trying Match Your Medicare. I appreciate your support, and I’d love your feedback.

Alex Doonanco, co-founder and CEO, careCycle

See your plans in seconds.

Free, unbiased, and private.

Members of the press can reach us at press@careCycle.ai.

Sources

  • Plan exits this year: recent Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) data.
  • Plan exits, 2018 to 2026: Meiselbach et al., research letter, JAMA, Feb. 18, 2026 (Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health and Georgetown University).
  • Agent disclaimer: the Third-Party Marketing Organization disclaimer required by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (42 CFR 422.2267).
  • Call volumes and patterns: careCycle’s platform data.